Katie Tallo's "Where Her Secrets Lie"

Katie Tallo has more than three decades of experience as an award-winning screenwriter and director. After winning an international novel contest, she began writing mystery thrillers. In 2020, her debut thriller, Dark August, was an instant bestseller, earning acclaim as a New York Times Book Review Editors’ Choice and an Apple Book of the Month. It also made the Globe 100 list. Since then, Tallo has written two more novels in the critically acclaimed Gus Monet trilogy including Poison Lilies and Buried Road. Her first standalone crime thriller, Where Her Secrets Lie, comes out August 2026 and her next thriller, The Last Villa, comes out in June 2027. Tallo lives with her husband in Ottawa where she is currently cooking up her next novel.

Here the author dreamcasts the lead for an adaptation of Where Her Secrets Lie:

If they make my book, Where Her Secrets Lie, into a film, I’d love to see Helen Mirren play the fiesty, wild-haired, beer-drinking protagonist, Lenny Bird. Helen is ten years older than Lenny but she’s got the vibe, the look, the sexy energy and the agency to pull off this edgy grandmother who takes on a ruthless crime boss. Her work in Mobland — hell, all her work — proves she’s got the gritty chops to be the perfect Lenny Bird.

While writing the novel and developing the lead character, I was very much inspired by a photo of Helen taken when she turned 70. It’s a sexy, fierce image of a beautiful older woman in her prime. Every time I looked at the photo, I got a little closer to understanding Lenny. It would be hard to imagine anyone else in the role.

Visit Katie Tallo's website.

The Page 69 Test: Dark August.

Q&A with Katie Tallo.

Writers Read: Katie Tallo (June 2022).

The Page 69 Test: Buried Road.

Writers Read: Katie Tallo (December 2024).

--Marshal Zeringue

Rachel Peterson's "Killing Sadie"

Rachel Peterson graduated from Miami University of Ohio with a degree in English and Creative Writing. After starting her career as a copywriter, she made the shift to the technology space and spent nearly a decade in New York City leading marketing teams for international tech companies before stepping away from the corporate world and focusing full-time on her career as an author. Peterson now splits her time between NYC and the Midwest, where she lives with her husband Ken, their dog Olive, and horse Hope.

Here Peterson dreamcasts an adaptation of her new YA thriller, Killing Sadie:

As a Midwestern kid who spent her early days dreaming of becoming an actor or author, my mind is constantly buzzing with who would play my characters!

We have quite a few characters to cover for Killing Sadie, so let’s focus on our twins, Sadie and Jayne Cooper. Sadie is our Midwestern golden girl with the personality to match, while Jayne is far edgier. But like most twins, they share an unspoken bond and are two sides of the same coin.

My mind jumps instantly to Isabel Gravitt (Tori Cooper in Your Friends and Neighbors), or Sadie Sink to play our twins! These two actresses have range for days, and can flip from polite to sinister in a second. And who are we kidding, every character in Killing Sadie needs to have this attribute! For their parents, Jon Hamm and Reese Witherspoon is a combination the world simply needs more of, full stop.

Putting my producer hat on, the mood for Killing Sadie leans camp and nostalgia, so if we can convince Sabrina Carpenter to return to acting, she might be my top spot for Liz! Or maybe India Lillie Davies from the AGGGTM universe, who played Andie Bell, a perfect comp for our party girl with hidden secrets.

Oh, and Jessica Beal or Simone Ashley as Detective Sloane, anyone? I could just die.

Visit Rachel Peterson's website.

--Marshal Zeringue

D. E. Carr's "When Squirrels Fly"

D. E. Carr has a career that spans the fields of neuropsychology, community health, and recreation management. She has a distance runner’s appreciation for the outdoors and thoroughly enjoys the humor and the brilliance of the residents of her adopted hometown of Ann Arbor, Michigan.

Here she dreamcasts an adaptation of her new novel, When Squirrels Fly:

When Mel Caldwell makes an animated, middle of the night phone call to her niece, Allie, but hangs up before explaining herself, Allie initially shrugs it off. Her aunt has always been a little eccentric. But when Aunt Mel disappears from her home less than 24 hours later, Allie drops everything and travels to Michigan to search for her. Shortly after her arrival in Ann Arbor, Allie meets her aunt’s enigmatic next-door neighbor, George Bennet. She reluctantly accepts help from George unaware he hides a dangerous secret that will complicate the search. The duo becomes a trio when Allie’s affable, but annoyingly irreverent younger brother, Nick, arrives to help. To find Aunt Mel, they’ll need to work together to determine how a neighborhood trellis, virtual reality goggles, migraine research, and an itinerant chihuahua, are all connected to the case.

When Squirrels Fly blends the popular genres of Cozy Mystery and light Science Fiction, both of which transition well to the screen. Although Ann Arbor, Michigan is a bit bigger than the typical small town cozy mystery setting, the action is mostly contained in a two-mile radius encompassing the historic Old West Side. The movie could be filmed on location in Ann Arbor where the somewhat quirky ambience allows the characters an easy backdrop for comic relief. There will be no shortage of extras with a wonderfully diverse population to choose from.

To imagine this cozy mystery-sci fi movie, think Hallmark Mysteries blended with a toned-down version of Everything, Everywhere, All At Once - Mystery 101 meets Something, Somewhere, Once in a While. This will be the vibe of When Squirrels Fly, the movie. I can already picture some entertaining special effects.

True to the cozy mystery genre, Allie Caldwell is an amateur sleuth; also, an accomplished associate professor of neuroscience from Colorado. I see her being played by Jennifer Lawrence whose characters are typically strong, clever, intuitive, witty and a tiny bit clumsy. She also has great chemistry with Bradley Cooper who I see as George Bennet. George is a sympathetic neighbor, but he’s complicated. The banter will flow easily between these two actors, just as it does in the book.

Allie has a playful, chaotic relationship with her younger brother Nick, whose world view is at opposite ends of the spectrum from hers. I think Chris Pratt – the one seen in television’s Parks & Recreation and not the raptor-whispering hero in Jurassic World – has the demeanor, comedic timing, and charisma to be a good Nick.

Mrs. Oakley, the spirited 85-year-old ballet instructor who doesn’t look a day over 65, lives across the street from Mel and knows a lot more than she lets on. I see her being played by Jamie Lee Curtis.

Finally, the floppy-eared, 8-pound, roving Chihuahua, Chidi, can only be played by my dog Cheech. He’ll need to lose a few pounds to fit the role, but he’ll think he owns the set by week two.

In order to maintain production deadlines, the film will need a director that can handle Chihuahua obstinacy. Wes Anderson is my ideal choice.

Visit D. E. Carr's website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Elizabeth H. Winthrop's "Conviction"

Elizabeth Hartley Winthrop was born and raised in New York City. She earned her B.A. from Harvard University and her M.F.A. in fiction from the UC Irvine, where she was the recipient of the Schaeffer Writing Fellowship. She is the author of the novels Fireworks, December, The Why of Things, and The Mercy Seat. She lives in Massachusetts with her husband and daughter and is Associate Professor of English/Creative Writing at Endicott College.

Here Winthrop dreamcasts an adaptation of her new novel, Conviction:

I honestly didn’t have any cinematic notions in mind when I wrote Conviction, but in answering the question of who I’d want to star in a movie adaptation was fun, and when I stumbled across the “right” actor for each role, I knew it immediately.

Saoirse Ronan could play Maggie; she has that quality of fierce interiority, and she's believable as someone whose idealism could harden into something dangerous without ever losing your sympathy.

Ramy Youssef could play Ahmet. He has enormous charm, quiet intelligence, and a genuine spiritual seriousness.

As for Ann, I think Laura Linney. She has that quality of holding enormous pain very tidily, and then it breaks through in unexpected moments. She's also believable as someone who gardens, who bakes a cake for no occasion, who sleeps on a futon since her husband died. Grounded and devastating.

Edward Norton could play Josh. There's something in him that suggests a person who acts from quiet conviction rather than performance, and he can play genuine goodness without it being boring. He has interior complexity, which matters for a character the audience only gets in memory and absence. And he's believable as a carpenter, a father, someone who spends ten hours in a barn.

Hiam Abbass would be perfect as Nour, who is novel’s moral center-- aged, physically worn but inwardly fierce. Hiam Abbass has exactly that quality of power held very quietly.

Finally, Ali Suliman could play Sirvan. He actually looks how I imagined Sirvan to look—and Sirvan is the only character I imagined. And as an actor Suliman is perfect; he has gravitas and a profound sadness he can access without effort.

Visit Elizabeth H. Winthrop's website.

--Marshal Zeringue

"Sisterhood Above All" by Kathleen Barber with Amayah Shaienne

Kathleen Barber is the author of Truth Be Told, which was adapted by Reese Witherspoon's Hello Sunshine as a series on AppleTV+, Follow Me, and Both Things Are True. A certified book coach and former attorney, she lives in Washington, DC, with her family.

Amayah Shaienne is a lifestyle content creator and student at the University of Alabama who quickly grew a following during Bama Rush. To date, she has garnered a following of nearly 200K across TikTok and Instagram and has her audience obsessed with all parts of her college life. She is excited to continue bringing her loyal followers along as she attends key college moments such as sorority rush, football games, and more.

Here Barber dreamcasts an adaptation of their new novel, Sisterhood Above All:

Like many authors, I love to imagine my work translated for the screen—but I always struggle with dreamcasting because I have such specific ideas of what my characters look like and how they behave. I’ve done my best, though, to dreamcast the three point-of-view characters in Sisterhood Above All:

Ava Nichols is a potential new member going through sorority rush who is desperate to join the Gammas. She’s blonde and conventionally pretty, but she’s anxious and unsure of herself. I’d cast Grace Van Patten as Ava based on appearance, but there’s a longing to fit in that reminds me of Maude Apatow’s performance as Lexi in Euphoria.

Madison Archer is the president of the Gammas. She’s intimidatingly beautiful—and intimidating, full stop. She’s cruel and calculating but knows how to put on a smile to get what she wants. If Madelaine Petsch were blonde, she’d be perfect—I loved her as Cheryl Blossom on Riverdale. I also see hints of Emma Roberts in her iconic roles as Chanel Oberlin in Scream Queens and Madison Montgomery in American Horror Story: Coven.

Shay Wright is the president of the Thetas. Smart, successful, and pretty, Shay is Type-A and driven to a fault. Her ambition threatens to push her beyond her physical limits, but she doesn’t know how to slow down. I’d cast Lovie Simone as Shay for her appearance, but there’s an anxious quality in Shay that reminds of Shay Mitchell’s Emily on Pretty Little Liars. (The character name is pure coincidence!)

While I’m at it, I’m going to dreamcast Christian Drake, Madison’s degenerate not-boyfriend. I definitely named him after Christian Slater for his role as Jason Dean in Heathers, but current Christian Slater is too old to play my Christian. My collaborator Amayah said she sees Christian as having Nate-from-Euphoria vibes, and I totally agree with her (seasons 1 and 2 Nate, of course, not whatever happened to Nate in season 3), so let’s cast Jacob Elordi.

Visit Kathleen Barber's website.

The Page 69 Test: Follow Me.

Writers Read: Kathleen Barber (March 2020).

12 Yoga Questions with Kathleen Barber.

The Page 69 Test: Both Things Are True.

My Book, The Movie: Both Things Are True.

Q&A with Kathleen Barber.

Writers Read: Kathleen Barber (September 2025).

--Marshal Zeringue

Bryan Gruley's "River Deep"

Bryan Gruley is the Edgar-nominated author of seven novels and one award-winning work of nonfiction. A lifelong journalist, he shared in The Wall Street Journal's Pulitzer Prize for coverage of the September 11 terrorist attacks. A longtime Chicago resident, he now lives in northern lower Michigan with his wife, Pamela.

Here Gruley dreamcasts an adaptation of his new novel, River Deep:

If River Deep was a movie or, my preference, a streamed series, I would hope for Vince Gilligan, creator of my favorite series ever, Breaking Bad, to direct this cast:

Isa Briones, the prickly young doctor in TV’s The Pitt, as our courtroom hero, Devyn Payne. She’s attractive enough, tough enough, saucy enough. Different from my pick in Bitterfrost (the young agent from hit TV series Slow Horses), but I’d never seen Briones before.

Fiona Dourif, also from The Pitt, as the accused murderer Catriona Dulaney (OK, my wife and I love that series, but so does everybody else). Dourif's character in The Pitt wears an ankle monitor—just like Catriona. And she’s a tough redhead.

Jeff Daniels, Michigan guy, as Detective Garth Klimmek. This was my pick for Bitterfrost and I’m sticking with it. Like Klimmek, Daniels is great at playing a semi-grumpy but honest character.

Billy Bob Thornton—hell, yeah—as Hooper. He looks like I imagine Hooper would look, and could easily adopt Hooper’s near-cynical view of humanity—minus the southern accent.

Kyle Chandler as Jimmy Baker. Jimmy doesn’t have a point-of-view role in River Deep, but he’s still an important character. Last time I chose Timothy Olyphant, which would work too, but Chandler has the rugged looks of a good guy like Jimmy.

Jodie Foster as Circuit Judge Darlene Esper. Foster would be great at delivering the judge’s comic skepticism and dominance of her little world. Kate Winslet would work just fine, too.

Jack Lowden as Sammy Hardt. The Slow Horses heartthrob would draw viewers into Sammy’s character and then—sorry, no spoilers. Jesse Plemons of Breaking Bad or even Daniel Radcliffe could step into Sammy’s shoes.

Visit Bryan Gruley's website.

The Page 69 Test: Starvation Lake.

The Page 69 Test: The Hanging Tree.

The Page 69 Test: Bleak Harbor.

The Page 69 Test: Purgatory Bay.

The Page 69 Test: Bitterfrost.

Q&A with Bryan Gruley.

My Book, The Movie: Bitterfrost.

--Marshal Zeringue

Peter Colt's "The Driftwood Bones"

Peter Colt is the author of Cold Island in the Detective Tommy Kelly series and the Andy Roark Mysteries. He was born in Boston, Massachusetts, in 1973 and is a graduate of the University of Rhode Island. Colt spent twenty-four years in the army reserve, with deployments to Kosovo in 2000 and Iraq in 2003 and 2008. He is currently a police officer in Providence, Rhode Island, where he lives with his family and two perpetually feuding cats. Colt’s hobbies include cooking, camping, and kayaking.

Here Colt dreamcasts an adaptation of his new novel, The Driftwood Bones, the second title featuring Detective Tommy Kelly:

If my book were a movie there are several characters I would like to see cast.

The protagonist Tommy Kelly is State Police Detective, who is a hot mess. His marriage is over, his love life is a mess, his career is on the ropes and he's been exiled to Nantucket Island by the State Police. I want an actor who can portray Kelly and his problems without turning it into the cliched "divorced, alcoholic" cop performance. I can see two potential leading men playing Kelly, Alexander Skarsgård, who gives outstanding performances in Generation Kill and Murderbot. Or Milo Ventimiglia whose performance in the series This Is Us shows the range he is capable of. Both actors could convincingly play a troubled police detective without turning it into a cliche.

The second character I want to see cast is Detective Jo Harris. Jo is neither a sidekick nor a typical film love interest. She is smart, tough and where Kelly is a hot mess Jo is the one who keeps the investigation on track. In many ways she's the real hero of the story. In my mind she looks like Florence Pugh. I think that Pugh has the chops to deliver a performance that would avoid all the stereotypes and tropes that the film industry often falls back on when portraying female cops. Pugh has shown us through a range of film roles that she can be tough, vulnerable, alluring and most importantly deliver a captivating performance.

Visit Peter Colt's website.

My Book, The Movie: Back Bay Blues.

The Page 69 Test: Back Bay Blues.

Q&A with Peter Colt.

The Page 69 Test: Death at Fort Devens.

My Book, The Movie: Death at Fort Devens.

Writers Read: Peter Colt (June 2022).

My Book, The Movie: The Ambassador.

The Page 69 Test: The Ambassador.

The Page 69 Test: The Judge.

My Book, The Movie: The Judge.

Writers Read: Peter Colt (May 2024).

Writers Read: Peter Colt (March 2025).

My Book, The Movie: The Banker.

The Page 69 Test: The Banker.

The Page 69 Test: Cold Island.

Writers Read: Peter Colt (September 2025).

My Book, The Movie: Cold Island.

--Marshal Zeringue

Kerri Hakoda's "Too Deep to Cross"

Kerri Hakoda has worked in and out of Alaska in advertising and marketing, marine transportation, cable television and trade magazine ad sales. She was born and raised in Hawaii, but now calls northwest Washington her home, where she lives with her husband (himself a veteran of the Alaska fishing industry) and writes mystery, historical, and young adult science fiction.

Here Hakoda dreamcasts an adaptation of her new novel, Too Deep to Cross: A Thriller:

Too Deep to Cross would be challenging to cast as a movie. In it, multi-racial Anchorage Homicide Detective DeHavilland Beans returns to his Yukon River hometown after a battered prosthetic leg from a local man washes up – and turns a long-cold missing person case into a homicide investigation. In the San Francisco Bay Area cleaning out the family home, Beans’ mother Mari makes unsettling discoveries of her own.

I envision a very specific look, a distinctive combination of ethnicities for DeHavilland Beans – he is half Japanese, a quarter Irish and a quarter Native Alaskan – a difficult casting combination. Maybe a younger Daniel Henney type, or Lewis Tan? It’s hard to find reasonably pleasant-looking Eurasian actors who aren’t martial artists, not that that’s a bad thing – I just don’t see Beans as being a blackbelt in anything. I like Henry Golding as well, but he may be too handsome and urbane.

For Beans’ mother Mari, who is Japanese American – I see Tamlyn Tomita, Joan Chen, or similarly attractive older Asian American woman.

Oddly enough, the antagonists are easier to cast, I think. I clearly see Vincent D’Onofrio as Victor Paul, the town’s overbearing shopkeeper, and Barry Keoghan as his over-indulged son Lloyd (and owner of the prosthetic leg).

Visit Kerri Hakoda's website.

Writers Read: Kerri Hakoda.

Q&A with Kerri Hakoda.

The Page 69 Test: Too Deep to Cross.

--Marshal Zeringue

Christine Gunderson's "Behind White Picket Fences"

Christine Gunderson is a former television anchor, reporter, and Capitol Hill press secretary, a suburban mother of three, and the author of Friends with Secrets.

She currently lives just outside Washington D.C. but grew up on a fourth-generation family farm in rural North Dakota. She loves Jane Austen, sailing, and Star Wars, and she can drive a tractor, a skill yet to be useful in her daily life.

Here Gunderson dreamcasts an adaptation of her new novel, Behind White Picket Fences:

One of the questions I am most often asked at book club meetings is this: Who would play the characters if my book were made into a movie?

I never know how to answer this question because inside my head, the people in my book are people, not characters, and I have a really hard time imagining them as anyone else, even famous actors.

But as release day approaches, I finally sat down and gave this question some serious thought.

Behind White Picket Fences is a book about three mothers who decide to take a break from modern motherhood. In the process, they try to re-create the kind of childhood they experienced as kids. Astute readers will notice subtle references to Leave It To Beaver, a TV show representing an idealized, bygone America.

Therefore, the character of Dottie in Behind White Picket Fences would be played by Barbara Billingsley, best known for her iconic role as June Cleaver, the perfect 1950’s era housewife and mother in Leave it to Beaver.

And yes, I realize this talented actress passed away in 2010 at the age of 94, but since we’re dream casting this movie, we can pretend she is still with us, lovely and gracious and in her prime.

The three modern moms in Behind White Picket Fences are easier to cast. Piper, the no-nonsense former diplomatic security agent would be played by Rebecca Ferguson. This actress is perhaps best known as Lady Jessica in the Dune franchise, but I came to love her as Juliette Nichols in Silo, a fantastic sort of dystopian/sci fi mash up tv series available on Apple TV.

Jennifer Garner’s wholesome goodness and comedic timing make her perfect for Kiersten, a big-hearted mom from the Midwest who sees the good in everyone, even when she shouldn’t.

Finally, Kristen Wiig would play Rosamund, the third mom on Beaverbrook Lane. She completes the trio of moms who discover something sinister on their seemingly perfect cull de sac.

I chose Kristen Wiig because she made me laugh until I cried in Bridesmaids, and this book and the subsequent movie adaptation should be equal parts suspense and humor, and I know she could balance both beautifully.

So that’s the dream team should Behind White Picket Fences ever get the call from Hollywood. Until then, they will continue to live inside my head, and, I hope, inside the hearts of readers. Which is probably best, because as every reader knows, the book is always better than the movie.

Visit Christine Gunderson's website.

Q&A with Christine Gunderson.

--Marshal Zeringue

DeAndra Davis's "The Lovers, the Liars, and Me"

DeAndra Davis is New York–born and Florida-bred. She’s a hopeless musical theater nerd (Wicked is definitely her favorite), a perpetual student and teacher, and always trailed by a kid or a dog because she has way too many of both. She has an opinion for everything, an argument ready, and a hug for everyone, and she thinks you should, too. She is the author of All the Noise at Once, winner of the William C. Morris Award for best young adult debut book, and The Lovers, the Liars, and Me.

Here Davis dreamcasts an adaptation of The Lovers, the Liars, and Me:

If it’s one thing I love, it’s a good face cast, and with this book, it was no different. I feel like The Lovers, the Liars, and Me is inherently visual with the descriptions of the island and locations. I tried to be lush and descriptive, and that also applies to characters in this love triangle romance meets contemporary drama. I definitely have a primary person in mind with my main character and her supporting cast of friends that I believe would bring the story to life.

Marsai Martin is my immediate choice for Jaliya. Marsai is a brilliant and gorgeous actress, and I know she could bring both the character to life aesthetically, and tap into that growth from hesitant, unsure teen to self-assured and confident. Marsai is also so funny, and I think she could get into the quippy banter the friend group has going in The Lovers, the Liars, and Me.

Jahi Winston would be my pick for Shevaughn, Jaliya’s cousin. I think his personality fits, and he could really bring the character to life in many ways. His acting catalogue is so varied and Shevaughn is a difficult character to play because he’s going through so much that he would need an actor who could approach his role with care.

For the two love interests, it was hard to choose but for India I would pick Storm Reid who has acted in many projects I’ve loved and who, after being in so many dramatic projects, can tackle those more difficult parts of India’s character while still bringing forth the charm she exudes every time she’s in a scene.

For Andre, I have to go with Caleb McLaughlin. I think he plays such an endearing love interest in Stranger Things (despite the horror backdrop) that I believe in a more relaxed setting, that could (and would) get played up even more, enhancing the interesting love triangle moment.

Last, for Deon, Jaliya’s best friend and the absolute funniest person in the book hands down, I pictured JD McCrary who has a background in some comedy and who would really do the character justice for all his clever, sarcastic humor throughout the book.

Visit DeAndra Davis's website. She can be found on most socials @DeAndraWrites.

--Marshal Zeringue