
Like the main character in her debut novel The Probable Son, Jiban has taught in middle schools and is raising two sons. She was born and raised in the Seattle area but has now lived with her family in St. Paul for over twenty years.
Here Jiban dreamcasts an adaptation of The Probable Son:
Teacher Elsa Vargas has always suspected that the boy she is raising is the wrong child, accidentally switched at birth. But because of her deep love for Bird, Elsa has planned to keep her doubts buried forever.Visit Cindy Jiban's website.
Then one day, a student named Thomas in her middle school classroom is uncannily familiar. When she learns that he shares a birthday with Bird, she realizes: Thomas is probably her son.
If she’s right, what will that mean for Bird?
Here’s my dream cast for The Probable Son:
Elsa, the mother
Casting Elsa well is critical. She is a warm and inherently funny mother and teacher who has to navigate the possibility of terrible loss. Still, her sometimes-clumsy search for the truth becomes a bit cringeworthy, at turns. Her yearning drives her forward, but her penchant for rattling the school parent community fills her path with obstacles.
I need an actress who can portray a layered Elsa: hilarious eyerolls but also escaped tears; clever planning but also moments of love-fueled but unhinged judgment.
To give us a complex and lovable Elsa we can’t look away from, I trust Emily Blunt.
Bird and Thomas, the possibly-switched sons
The son Elsa has been mothering, Bird, is a quiet and serious optimist within a family of extroverted skeptics. Meanwhile, Thomas is a charismatic questioner of the world, someone much more like the rest of Elsa’s family. Both are eighth graders who turn fourteen years old in front of us, a fleeting and awkward in-between time where boys grow wide shoulders to go with their still-soft faces.
Casting a young fourteen-year-old requires magic, perhaps freezing time. Instead, I’ll point to magic moments from the past.
As sweet and endangered Bird, I cast River Phoenix in the year of Stand by Me.
As magnetic and eager Thomas, I cast a young Tom Holland, perhaps one year before his Peter Parker was first bitten by that spider.
More roles
If money is no object, then let’s pack this cast.
As Elsa’s lovable and effortfully resilient husband: Jake Gyllenhaal.
As the hot, single-mom president of the PTA, exasperated by Elsa: Reese Witherspoon.
As the quiet mother raising Thomas instead of Bird: a mousey Carey Mulligan.
As the perceptive teacher friend, one classroom over: Quinta Brunson.
As Elsa’s snarkily over-honest sister: Anna Kendrick.
And as the best friend, whose best might not be good enough: Ali Wong.
Meanwhile…
The film is… held up, currently. But the book comes out December 2nd . Given these facts, it seems fair to say: The book is better.
--Marshal Zeringue








