Verlin Darrow's "The Brighter the Light, the Darker the Shadow"

Verlin Darrow is a psychotherapist who lives with his psychotherapist wife in the woods near the Monterey Bay in northern California. They diagnose each other as necessary. Darrow is a former professional volleyball player (in Italy), unsuccessful country-western singer/songwriter, import store owner, and assistant guru in a small, benign spiritual organization.

Here he dreamcasts an adaptation of his new novel, The Brighter the Light, the Darker the Shadow:

Since the protagonist of The Brighter the Light, the Darker the Shadow—Kade Tobin—is the leader of a spiritual community who may or may not have a sketchy background, casting would be challenging. On the one hand, an actor would need to have enough gravitas to make it believable that seekers would follow him and respect his teachings. On the other hand, he’d need to be able to at least hint that there was more to him than just the beneficent guy he seems to be at first. In other words, the part would call for someone who could project complexity—be a bit of a mystery in and of himself. After all, this is a story of murder, and everyone’s a suspect.

I suppose a classically trained English actor well-versed in an American accent would work. Forgetting ages, I’m thinking of people like Anthony Hopkins, Jeremy Irons, Patrick Stewart, and Peter O’Toole. Each of their voices has a commanding or self- assured element, and I respect their abilities to play diverse roles.

The detective who works with Kade—Bill Cullen—could be played by a number of people, including Walton Goggins, Colin Farrell, Vincent D’Onofrio, or Jon Tenney (he was on The Closer, and usually isn’t the main character in films. I picked him because we grew up four houses apart and he has a generic look to him.) I wouldn’t want the detective role played in a distracting, powerhouse fashion, so the actor would need to rein in his performance. Cullen is a slow and steady guy who’s easy to underestimate.

The prosecutor in the extended trail scenes could be played by Rhea Seehorn. It’s easy to settle on just one choice with this one. She portrayed just the right proportions of competence, vulnerability, and showmanship in Better Call Saul.

I’m not sure about the defense attorney. Like Detective Cullen, he’s not impressive at first, but he turns out to be an excellent trial lawyer. We only know him as a member of Kade’s flock for most of the book, complicating the casting. Who could appear to be both spiritual-minded and good at arguing? Beats me.

In The Brighter the Light, the Darker the Shadow, a lot of quirky community members are questioned as suspects. Some examples: an illegal Basque immigrant, an African-American former Buddhist nun, a fugitive hiding out as the community’s chef, and the prosecutor’s daughter. Of course, the details about these folks aren’t known at the outset. I can picture the faces of various character actors who would be right for many of these characters, but I don’t know their names or how to find out.

Visit Verlin Darrow's website.

Writers Read: Verlin Darrow (May 2023).

My Book, The Movie: Murder for Liar.

The Page 69 Test: Murder for Liar.

The Page 69 Test: The Not Quite Enlightened Sleuth.

Writers Read: Verlin Darrow (April 2024).

My Book, The Movie: The Not Quite Enlightened Sleuth.

--Marshal Zeringue